.:Project Alfheim:.
3x/3x/5x
Server Rating Summary
[?]
Server Rating:
Community Rating:
Game Master Rating:
Game-Play Rating:
Stability
80%
Availability
88%
Community Rating:
Friendliness
73%
Eventfulness
65%
Game Master Rating:
Friendliness
72%
Availability
72%
Helpfulness
72%
Game-Play Rating:
Economy
69%
Guild Play
66%
Class Balance
75%
Average Rating:
73 / 100
Population Median Reference:
300
Donation Level:
Unavailable
18%
Balanced
78%
Imbalance
4%
Customization Level:
Unavailable
4%
Occasional
36%
Extensive
60%
| Dominco | Played for more than 1 year | 2024-01-06 |
After a year playing i can write a solid review, i'd say the server is balanced in terms of economy and class diversity, admin made some custom changes that makes this Pre Renewall server not so hard as you might think. If you are new you can easily establish and community is friendly so you can ask on main for ''newbie tips''. Admin perspective sometimes is very rigid and i did not like some of his decisious but i respect that, upcoming patches may catch your attention so stay tuned.
Server
Stability: 9
Availability: 9
Stability: 9Availability: 9
Community
Friendliness: 8
Eventfulness: 3
Friendliness: 8Eventfulness: 3
Game Masters
Friendliness: 5
Availability: 4
Helpfulness: 6
Friendliness: 5Availability: 4Helpfulness: 6
Game-play
Economy: 8
Guild Competition: 8
Class Balance: 8
Economy: 8Guild Competition: 8Class Balance: 8
| lina_91 | Played for more than 1 year | 2024-01-06 |
Been playing on this server for a while now.
PVM Community is always friendly and helpful. There's lots of partys.
WoE got changed because 1 person kept complaining to the admin repeatedly.
Players get guilt tripped for not being strong enough in WoE.
WoE is streamed by the admin, which is nice. But the admin being on voice with an alliance leader during it. Quite questionable
Server
Stability: 5
Availability: 2
Stability: 5Availability: 2
Community
Friendliness: 7
Eventfulness: 1
Friendliness: 7Eventfulness: 1
Game Masters
Friendliness: 5
Availability: 2
Helpfulness: 3
Friendliness: 5Availability: 2Helpfulness: 3
Game-play
Economy: 5
Guild Competition: 2
Class Balance: 5
Economy: 5Guild Competition: 2Class Balance: 5
Owner's reply to this review:
2024-01-06
some of these ratings are super arbitrary i notice. server availability a 2? stability 5? we haven't had a crash in quite awhile.
I cannot stress enough as I don't know where these hive mind accusations come from, but all WOE decisions are made by me and solely by me. I do not listen to guild leaders or players. I never have.
As for my WOE stream, the player helping me out was there purely to add commentary was not participating. Is disgusting that this is being portrayed as something its not
| danigermanxoxo | Played for more than 1 year | 2024-01-04 |
It's a dead server, but of course the server owner will say it's not dead and use a weird @$$ metric of "unique logins". GMs also follow the command of a certain player. If Xellie doesn't like something expect it to be changed on the next day or next patch. Played here over a year and doing RMT without them knowing, just shows how incompetent the GMs in this server.
Server
Stability: 5
Availability: 5
Stability: 5Availability: 5
Community
Friendliness: 5
Eventfulness: 5
Friendliness: 5Eventfulness: 5
Game Masters
Friendliness: 1
Availability: 1
Helpfulness: 1
Friendliness: 1Availability: 1Helpfulness: 1
Game-play
Economy: 5
Guild Competition: 5
Class Balance: 5
Economy: 5Guild Competition: 5Class Balance: 5
Owner's reply to this review:
2024-01-05
Server is not dead, unique players is the most accurate reflection of the playerbase. Would you rather I use non-unique as a measure? Include dual clients and mislead players? Pretty silly.
And yet another person spreading lies/misinformation about Xellie bias. There is absolutely no bias towards any player, let alone Xellie. Just pure nonsense.
| asdfghjklqwertyuiop | Played for 2 months | 2024-01-04 |
Server is not casual or solo friendly at all. This should be priority # 1 because
1: Players quit
2: New players replace them
If you don't have 2 anymore because the solo/casual/new experience is sh!t, you end up with a server in population decline. Charlie seems very well intentioned, but might be burned out/busy, and stubborn on their priorities, and can't deliver things in a timely manner
Don't join if you don't want to beg to join parties or aren't bringing multiple friends
Server
Stability: 10
Availability: 10
Stability: 10Availability: 10
Community
Friendliness: 1
Eventfulness: 1
Friendliness: 1Eventfulness: 1
Game Masters
Friendliness: 10
Availability: 10
Helpfulness: 10
Friendliness: 10Availability: 10Helpfulness: 10
Game-play
Economy: 1
Guild Competition: 1
Class Balance: 1
Economy: 1Guild Competition: 1Class Balance: 1
| 9ToesBin | Played for 3 months | 2024-01-03 |
Dead Server. Not much activities for new players.
The server peaks around 200+ most of them uses multi client and half of them are just sitting in town chatting.
The community has a cult-like behavior where they convince new players that mindless grinding is fun while they are doing the end-game content such as boss hunts and dungeon runs.
Grinding is not rewarding.
Only 2-3 guilds participating in GVG and no battleground.
GMs are easily offended so you have to walk on eggshells around them
Server
Stability: 7
Availability: 9
Stability: 7Availability: 9
Community
Friendliness: 3
Eventfulness: 5
Friendliness: 3Eventfulness: 5
Game Masters
Friendliness: 1
Availability: 5
Helpfulness: 1
Friendliness: 1Availability: 5Helpfulness: 1
Game-play
Economy: 5
Guild Competition: 1
Class Balance: 5
Economy: 5Guild Competition: 1Class Balance: 5
Owner's reply to this review:
2024-01-04
Im not sure in what world a server with 750+ unique players is dead, but ok.
Some of these other issues you say are subjective, but staff is already on record for having said that we agree that solo play isn't in the best spot and we're going to work on it. we're also working on improving the PVP/GVG experience as well. things take time people.
| Yunalisa | Played for 1 month | 2024-01-03 |
While I appreciate the core gameplay of this server, I've encountered significant issues. The GMs seem unresponsive to player feedback, creating a sense of disconnect. The lack of an installer for the client is a minor but notable inconvenience. Also, the vast power gap between new and veteran players makes progression feel daunting. Lastly, the option system, although a good concept, fails to impact gameplay....no build diversity.
Server
Stability: 6
Availability: 6
Stability: 6Availability: 6
Community
Friendliness: 5
Eventfulness: 5
Friendliness: 5Eventfulness: 5
Game Masters
Friendliness: 1
Availability: 1
Helpfulness: 1
Friendliness: 1Availability: 1Helpfulness: 1
Game-play
Economy: 3
Guild Competition: 5
Class Balance: 2
Economy: 3Guild Competition: 5Class Balance: 2
Owner's reply to this review:
2024-01-04
Some of these are hard to respond to as theyre purely subjective, but the last one is just objectively not true. there's a wide array of build diversity with some builds that are usually not possible in RO becoming meta here. If you weren't able to find a fun build you likely did not experiment enough or ask what other players have done differently.
As for feedback to players, I'm not sure what you expect. I've been pretty responsive, it's just adjustments take time.
| KazookieCrisps | Played for more than 1 year | 2023-12-31 |
Pre-Re with major quality-of-life adjustments. Random options on gear, Agi/Bless inn, fast sit regen, Alch mats drop multi, MVP instances, Acid Terror rebalanced to worthy skill. Efficiency skills for Alch/BS that use a catalyst to grant 10-min buff where you don't use Acid Bottles/zeny for AT/CT. It breathed new life into my smith!
After ep13, Renewal content is being rebalanced for pre-re. Old Glast Heim (epA-1) was just released as non-instanced maps.
Pre-re for modern times. Very fun!
Server
Stability: 9
Availability: 10
Stability: 9Availability: 10
Community
Friendliness: 9
Eventfulness: 8
Friendliness: 9Eventfulness: 8
Game Masters
Friendliness: 9
Availability: 7
Helpfulness: 9
Friendliness: 9Availability: 7Helpfulness: 9
Game-play
Economy: 8
Guild Competition: 7
Class Balance: 9
Economy: 8Guild Competition: 7Class Balance: 9
| hellouwu | Played for more than 1 year | 2023-12-31 |
The server is still fun 1 year in but the delayed updates due to unobtainable goals has hit the population numbers to a point we're at something like 1/5th the population we had at the beginning of 2023. I hope Charlie takes it upon himself to begin looking for and accepting help from those offering, as the two-man squad(on purpose) just isn't enough for a server of this size and scope. More than anything the players want consistency whether it's monthly costume boxes and patreon or updates.
Server
Stability: 9
Availability: 9
Stability: 9Availability: 9
Community
Friendliness: 9
Eventfulness: 7
Friendliness: 9Eventfulness: 7
Game Masters
Friendliness: 7
Availability: 8
Helpfulness: 8
Friendliness: 7Availability: 8Helpfulness: 8
Game-play
Economy: 8
Guild Competition: 8
Class Balance: 8
Economy: 8Guild Competition: 8Class Balance: 8
| BlaXun | Played for 1 month | 2023-12-25 |
Really cool server with some custom stuff that is mostly QoL. The admins have a good grasp bout the game and its mechanics and improve it in meaningful ways without adding overpowered Private Server stuff. Really cool. Hope more people will join as the server is really a lot of fun to play on.
Server
Stability: 8
Availability: 8
Stability: 8Availability: 8
Community
Friendliness: 9
Eventfulness: 8
Friendliness: 9Eventfulness: 8
Game Masters
Friendliness: 9
Availability: 8
Helpfulness: 8
Friendliness: 9Availability: 8Helpfulness: 8
Game-play
Economy: 6
Guild Competition: 7
Class Balance: 9
Economy: 6Guild Competition: 7Class Balance: 9
| HeisserOfen | Played for 4 months | 2023-12-12 |
I've been playing on this Server for around 4 month now and every day I enjoy being online. The Server Rates are not extrem and leveling is fun. The custom stuff is balanced, no p2w cash shop. The cash shop contains only costumes without stats. Also there is a very own custom dungeon, there will be custom classes and more and more custom stuff. There is no mistake looking into it!~
Server
Stability: 10
Availability: 10
Stability: 10Availability: 10
Community
Friendliness: 10
Eventfulness: 10
Friendliness: 10Eventfulness: 10
Game Masters
Friendliness: 10
Availability: 10
Helpfulness: 10
Friendliness: 10Availability: 10Helpfulness: 10
Game-play
Economy: 10
Guild Competition: 10
Class Balance: 10
Economy: 10Guild Competition: 10Class Balance: 10
